Profile illustrative

Dimensions weight · score

click a dimension for its 3 criteria

technical due diligence7 dimensions · 21 criteria
weighted score risk class red flags

VC method inputs

no tech-risk surcharge
return multiple
required stake
post-money
pre-money

Try it: set the scores, watch the risk class change, and see what technical risk does to the valuation.

context

Hardware startups fail differently from software startups. In the VC method, technical risk only enters through the investor's gut-feel return multiple, so a hardware startup's valuation depends on how risky it feels, not on how mature it is.

the model

  • 7 dimensions with 3 criteria each, every criterion scored 1 to 5 against written score anchors
  • Weighted total: technology readiness and verification 20% each, integration, reliability and manufacturing 15% each, regulatory 10%, supply chain 5%
  • Red-flag rule: any single criterion at 1 is reported separately, so one fatal gap cannot be averaged away
  • Risk classes: I from 4.0, II from 3.0, III from 2.0, IV below 2.0

link to the VC method

Each risk class sets a surcharge on the required return multiple: none for class I, 20 to 30% for class II, 50 to 75% for class III, and no investment for class IV. In the worked example, a score of 2.40 lowers the pre-money valuation from €9.86M to €5.29M, a 46.3% drop that would otherwise stay hidden in the investor's intuition.

validation

  • Expert interviews with investors from three venture funds, including a corporate VC
  • A case study with a pre-seed hardware startup
  • A consistency check with 10 AI agents in different investor roles over 3 runs: 28 valid assessments of the same fictional startup landed within a narrow band around 2.4

result

Thesis and colloquium both graded 1.0. The surcharges are orientation corridors, not market-calibrated values, which the thesis states openly.

skills

technical due diligence · venture capital · vc method · mcda · research design · llm evaluation